Best Insurance Brokers in Dunedin

We assessed 14 insurance brokers in Dunedin and ranked the top 5 on public rating quality, review volume and how recent the reviews are. The businesses listed below hold 1,289 Google reviews between them. No business can pay for a place in these rankings. Last updated 27 October 2026. How we rank

Top 5 Insurance Brokers in Dunedin

The top 5 insurance brokers in Dunedin are #1 MortgageMe, #2 Josh Cuttance Insurance & KiwiSaver SHARE, #3 Rothbury, #4 Dr. Nina Giles, and #5 Insure Otago, ranked by Top5 Score.

  • 1

    MortgageMe

    ★ 5.0 814 reviews +21 Score 199 -1
    Highest
    5★ 798 4★ 13 3★ 1 1★ 2

    MortgageMe walks first-home buyers through mortgages, refinancing, renovation loans, and KiwiSaver investment, with named advisers like Becky, Hayden, Daryl, and Marie each taking close ownership of their clients' situations.

    155 Princes Street, Central Dunedin, Dunedin

  • 2

    Josh Cuttance Insurance & KiwiSaver SHARE

    ★ 5.0 178 reviews +2 Score 171
    27.5 behind
    5★ 177 4★ 1

    Advisers Taylor and Josh set up life insurance, health cover, trauma cover, and business insurance, including for clients with complex health histories that other brokers find difficult to place.

    265 Princes Street, Central Dunedin, Dunedin

    Call 027 742 7333 Map Is this your business?
  • 3

    Rothbury Insurance Brokers Otago

    ★ 4.9 115 reviews +2 Score 164
    35.0 behind
    5★ 110 4★ 4 1★ 1

    Rothbury coordinates business insurance, forestry cover, and personal insurance packages, with named brokers like Ursula, Becky, Kerri, and Anna each taking ownership of individual client relationships over multiple years.

    Public Trust Bldg Level 2/442 Moray Place, Dunedin

    Call 03 477 8217 Map Is this your business?
  • 4

    Dr. Nina Giles - Health and Life Solutions Limited - Dunedin

    ★ 5.0 53 reviews +3 Score 155
    43.9 behind
    5★ 53

    Dr.

    9 Rennie Street, Green Island, Dunedin

    Call 021 165 1565 Map Is this your business?
  • 5

    Insure Otago

    ★ 5.0 45 reviews +1 Score 154
    44.9 behind
    5★ 43 4★ 2

    Insure Otago spots claims clients hadn't considered making, then guides them through the full process for health insurance, life insurance, and income protection cover.

    Petridish Building Level 2/8 Stafford Street, Central Dunedin, Dunedin

More rankings

More services in Dunedin 7 links
Insurance Brokers elsewhere in New Zealand 3 links

Before you choose an insurance broker in Dunedin

Insurance brokers and advisers access multiple insurers and can often find better business or personal cover at lower cost than going direct. Ask how many insurers they work with, how they are remunerated (and by whom), and what their process is when you need to make a claim.

The questions below are drawn from 157 customer reviews collected for this page.

What does an insurance broker cost, and who pays?

In New Zealand, the insurer pays your broker a commission, not you directly, with rates commonly ranging from 10% to 30% of your annual premium. Some brokers also charge a flat fee or hourly rate, particularly for complex commercial work, and this must be disclosed upfront.

Under the Financial Markets Conduct Act, brokers are legally required to tell you how they are paid before giving advice. You have the right to ask for the specific percentage or dollar amount, and you can verify a broker is licensed by searching the Financial Service Providers Register at the Companies Office website.

Does the broker compare policies from all insurers, or just a panel they work with?

Most New Zealand brokers work from a panel of insurers rather than the full market, and panel sizes vary widely, from a handful of providers to fifteen or more. There is no legal minimum on how many insurers a broker must compare, so the scope of comparison differs significantly between firms.

Ask any broker directly how many insurers are on their panel and whether they have access to wholesale or specialist markets not available to you directly. Commission arrangements with specific insurers can influence recommendations, so knowing the panel size and payment structure together gives you a clearer picture of how independent the advice actually is.

What does a broker actually do when I need to make a claim?

A good broker acts as your advocate with the insurer, handling paperwork, pushing back on disputes, and keeping the process moving on your behalf. Reviews here show brokers stepping in on serious claims, including a cancer diagnosis case where the broker's involvement made a genuinely stressful process manageable. One negative review flags the opposite experience, where a broker sided with the insurer rather than the client, which is the real risk when this relationship breaks down.

What are the warning signs of an insurance broker you shouldn't use?
  • –A broker who presents only one insurer's product without explaining why alternatives were ruled out.
  • –No upfront disclosure of how they are paid or what commission they receive from the insurer.
  • –Vague or evasive answers about policy exclusions, particularly for pre-existing conditions or specific claim scenarios.
  • –Poor availability when a claim arises, with slow responses or no proactive contact during the process.
  • –No offer to review your cover when your circumstances change, such as a new property, business, or family situation.
  • –One reviewer described a broker who sided with the insurer rather than advocating for the client, which is a direct failure of the broker's core role.
What should you ask before taking out a policy through a broker?
  • –How many insurers are on your panel, and have you compared options across all of them for my situation?
  • –How are you paid, and what is the specific commission percentage or fee that applies to the policy you are recommending?
  • –What is your process if I need to make a claim, and will you actively advocate with the insurer on my behalf?
  • –What is excluded from this policy, including any conditions or circumstances specific to my situation?
  • –How often will you review my cover, and will you contact me proactively if my policy needs updating?
  • –Are there any conflicts of interest I should know about, including preferred insurer relationships?
Top 5 Insurance Brokers in Dunedin badge

Run one of these businesses?

Verify your listing and put this badge on your own website. It's free, takes two minutes, and the badge keeps up with your rank at every check.

Verify and get your badge

About this ranking

What the 10 insurance brokers listed above hold, at the 27 October 2026 check.

814
reviews held by the #1 ranked business
45
reviews held by the #5 ranked business
4.9
lowest rating among the 10 listed
0.2%
of their 1,289 reviews are one-star

We first assessed insurance brokers in Dunedin in March 2026 and have rechecked the ranking four times since. MortgageMe has held first place at every check, and Josh Cuttance Insurance & KiwiSaver SHARE, Rothbury and Dr. Nina Giles have been in the top 5 alongside it throughout.

What has changed since March 2026?
Oct 2026

Dan Murphy Insurance Adviser entered the list at #9.

Sep 2026

Findex entered the list at #8.

Jul 2026

Insure Otago entered the top 5, up from #7. Insurance Link Otago left the top 5, down to #7.

May 2026

Insurance Link Otago entered the top 5, up from #6.

Mar 2026

First check. MortgageMe #1.

We updated the scoring method in May, July and October 2026. See what changed.

How are the top insurance brokers in Dunedin chosen?

We build this page from Google Maps results for insurance brokers in Dunedin. Each one is scored on its public rating and review record, using the same published method on every page. Businesses outside the area, or whose reviews describe a different line of work, are left out. Every category and city is rechecked on a rolling cycle, about every two to three months. See how we rank for how rankings are made and who is left out.

Are you an insurance broker in Dunedin?

No business can pay for a place in these rankings. Claiming and verifying your listing is free: it adds a small trust bonus (+3 points) to your score, for confirming a real operator stands behind the listing, and gives you a dashboard showing how your score is made up. A paid subscription adds a website link, a profile page and your ranking history. Claim your listing or see what a subscription includes.

Not listed? The usual reasons are a Google Business category that does not match, too few reviews to score near the top, or an address outside the area we cover. Check where you rank first, and if you think we missed you, get in touch.

How far is each one from you?

Type your suburb or use your location, and we'll show the distance on every card. The order stays the same.