Best Insurance Brokers on the North Shore

We assessed 44 insurance brokers on the North Shore and ranked the top 5 on public rating quality, review volume and how recent the reviews are. The businesses listed below hold 1,364 Google reviews between them. No business can pay for a place in these rankings. Last updated 27 October 2026. How we rank

This ranking covers businesses on the North Shore. For all of Auckland, see Insurance Brokers in Auckland.

Top 5 Insurance Brokers on the North Shore

The top 5 insurance brokers on the North Shore are #1 Provident Insurance, #2 Lifestyle Cover, #3 AA Insurance, #4 Baileys Insurance Brokers, and #5 Rodgers Insurance Advisers, ranked by Top5 Score.

  • 1

    Provident Insurance Corporation Limited

    ★ 4.6 665 reviews +23 Score 188 +12
    Highest
    5★ 559 4★ 55 3★ 9 2★ 2 1★ 40

    Provident Insurance gets vehicle claims moving fast, with approvals regularly coming through within hours of a single phone call and staff completing the process on the client's behalf from there.

    L1/61 Hurstmere Road, Takapuna, Auckland

    Call 0800 676 864 Map Is this your business?
  • 2

    Lifestyle Cover NZ Limited

    ★ 5.0 100 reviews +4 Score 164 +2
    23.5 behind
    5★ 96 4★ 4

    Lifestyle Cover works through health, life, and kids cover with clients who have put off sorting insurance, taking the time to match policy details to actual budgets and family circumstances.

    7h Douglas Alexander Parade, Rosedale, Auckland

    Call 0508 738 439 Map Is this your business?
  • 3

    AA Insurance Customer Service Centre - Auckland North

    ↑ 6
    ★ 4.4 179 reviews +1 Score 158 +7
    29.6 behind
    5★ 129 4★ 24 3★ 13 2★ 1 1★ 12

    AA Insurance steps in at stressful moments, with staff like Sharon and Lucy known for patiently sorting account confusion, answering questions, and getting cover arranged on the spot.

    144A Target Road, Wairau Valley, Auckland

    Call 0800 900 051 Map Is this your business?
  • 4

    Baileys Insurance Brokers

    ↓ 1
    ★ 4.9 63 reviews +3 Score 157 +1
    30.3 behind
    5★ 57 4★ 5 3★ 1

    Baileys Insurance Brokers is the go-to for marine and boat insurance, with brokers like Pete, Carolyn, and Shane known for sourcing competitive premiums, advising on exclusions, and getting cover arranged fast.

    9/35 Apollo Drive, Rosedale, Auckland

    Call 09 444 8860 Map Is this your business?
  • 5

    Rodgers Insurance Advisers Ltd

    ★ 5.0 70 reviews +1 Score 157 +2
    30.6 behind
    5★ 69 4★ 1

    Rodgers Insurance Advisers takes on health, life, and income protection insurance, with Mike known for chasing approvals on difficult claims with tight timeframes so clients never have to follow up themselves.

    27 Maygrove Drive, Orewa, Auckland

    Call 027 256 8362 Map Is this your business?

More rankings

Insurance Brokers elsewhere in Auckland 2 links
More services on the North Shore 7 links
Insurance Brokers elsewhere in New Zealand 3 links

Before you choose an insurance broker on the North Shore

Insurance brokers and advisers access multiple insurers and can often find better business or personal cover at lower cost than going direct. Ask how many insurers they work with, how they are remunerated (and by whom), and what their process is when you need to make a claim.

The questions below are drawn from 200 customer reviews collected for this page.

What does an insurance broker cost, and who pays?

In New Zealand, brokers are paid by insurers through commissions, not directly by you as the client. Commission rates run from 10% to 30% of your annual premium depending on the insurance type.

Some brokers charge a flat fee or hourly rate for complex commercial work, and this must be disclosed upfront. Under the Financial Markets Conduct Act 2013, brokers licensed through the Financial Markets Authority (FMA) must tell you how they are paid before providing advice, and you can ask for the exact percentage or dollar amount.

Does the broker compare policies from all insurers, or just a panel they work with?

Most NZ brokers work from a panel of insurers, which can range from three or four up to fifteen or more, so no single broker covers the entire market. There is no regulatory minimum on panel size set by the Financial Markets Authority (FMA), meaning a broker could technically compare just two or three products.

Reviews show that brokers who shopped across multiple insurers delivered meaningful premium savings, with some clients reporting reductions of 20% to 40% on commercial policies. Before committing, ask directly how many insurers are on their panel, whether they have access to wholesale markets, and what commission arrangements might influence which product they recommend.

What does a broker actually do when I need to make a claim?

A good broker acts as your advocate, chasing the insurer for approvals, managing paperwork, and keeping you updated so you are not left guessing. Reviews show that in complex situations, such as difficult medical histories, tight pre-approval deadlines, or disputed claim splits, a proactive broker can make a material difference to the outcome. Where brokers fell short, the pattern was the same: clients had to follow up repeatedly themselves, received no explanation when claims were handled in ways that felt unfair, and were left without a contact who would push back on the insurer on their behalf.

What are the warning signs of an insurance broker you shouldn't use?
  • –Poor payment administration, such as failing to process premiums on the dates agreed, signals unreliable back-office processes that could leave your cover at risk.
  • –A broker who dismisses you as not worth their time before understanding your situation is unlikely to advocate for you during a claim.
  • –Splitting a single claim into two to collect two excesses, without any proactive explanation to the client, is a red flag for a conflict of interest.
  • –Slow or absent communication when a claim is underway, where you have to chase every update yourself, suggests the broker is not actively managing your file.
  • –No discussion of policy exclusions before you sign means you may only discover gaps in cover at claim time, which is the worst moment to find out.
  • –A broker who has never reviewed your cover since you first signed up is not fulfilling the ongoing advisory role that justifies their commission.
What should you ask before taking out a policy through a broker?
  • –Ask how many insurers are on their panel and whether they have access to wholesale or specialist markets not available directly to consumers.
  • –Ask exactly how they are paid, including the commission percentage or flat fee, and whether that arrangement creates any preference for a particular insurer.
  • –Ask what their process is when you need to make a claim, specifically whether they manage the process on your behalf or simply pass you to the insurer.
  • –Ask what is specifically excluded from the policy being recommended, not just what is covered, and request that exclusions be explained in plain language before you sign.
  • –Ask how often they will proactively review your cover, and whether they will contact you if your circumstances change or if a better-value option becomes available.
  • –Confirm they hold a current licence by searching the Financial Service Providers Register (FSPR) at the Companies Office website before handing over any personal or financial information.
Top 5 Insurance Brokers on the North Shore badge

Run one of these businesses?

Verify your listing and put this badge on your own website. It's free, takes two minutes, and the badge keeps up with your rank at every check.

Verify and get your badge

About this ranking

What the 10 insurance brokers listed above hold, at the 27 October 2026 check.

665
reviews held by the #1 ranked business
70
reviews held by the #5 ranked business
4.4
lowest rating among the 10 listed
4.0%
of their 1,364 reviews are one-star

We first assessed insurance brokers on the North Shore in March 2026 and have rechecked the ranking five times since. Provident Insurance has held first place since September 2026. Lifestyle Cover has been in the top 5 at every check.

What has changed since March 2026?
Oct 2026

AA Insurance entered the top 5, up from #9. Hamer Pinnington left the top 5, down to #6.

Sep 2026

New first place: Provident Insurance. Provident Insurance returned to the top 5 at #1. Hamer Pinnington entered the top 5, up from #8. Rodgers Insurance Advisers entered the top 5 at #5. Rothbury North Shore left the top 5, down to #6. Halo Advisers left the top 5, down to #8. Futureproof Life, AA Insurance and Network Financial Services entered the list.

Jun 2026

Hamer Pinnington entered the list at #8.

May 2026

Baileys Insurance Brokers entered the top 5, up from #6.

Mar 2026

First check.

We updated the scoring method in May, June, August and October 2026. See what changed.

Months where nothing changed at the top are not listed.

How are the top insurance brokers on the North Shore chosen?

We build this page from Google Maps results for insurance brokers on the North Shore. Each one is scored on its public rating and review record, using the same published method on every page. Businesses outside the area, or whose reviews describe a different line of work, are left out. Every category and city is rechecked on a rolling cycle, about every two to three months. See how we rank for how rankings are made and who is left out.

Are you an insurance broker on the North Shore?

No business can pay for a place in these rankings. Claiming and verifying your listing is free: it adds a small trust bonus (+3 points) to your score, for confirming a real operator stands behind the listing, and gives you a dashboard showing how your score is made up. A paid subscription adds a website link, a profile page and your ranking history. Claim your listing or see what a subscription includes.

Not listed? The usual reasons are a Google Business category that does not match, too few reviews to score near the top, or an address outside the area we cover. Check where you rank first, and if you think we missed you, get in touch.

How far is each one from you?

Type your suburb or use your location, and we'll show the distance on every card. The order stays the same.